Pg.1 Author
                                                                                                                         Reviewer No.
MEDICAL IMAGE ANALYSIS (MedIA)
REVIEW FORM

 
Manuscript Number: #A
Title :
Author(s) :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thank you for agreeing to review the above paper. Please amplify answers on the next  page. The authors should have sufficient information to understand the basis of your  criticisms. In response to the questions below, please rate your answers using "0" (lowest)  to "5" (highest).

Summary : In one sentence, what is this paper all about?
 
 

1. Content

Is the paper of enough importance to warrant publication in MedIA?

Is the paper technically sound ?

Does the paper describe original work?

Is the work of interest to the MedIA audience?

Does the paper contain material which might well be omitted?

Should anything be added?

Does the paper make adequate references?
 

2. Presentation

Is the abstract an adequate digest of the work reported?

Does the introduction give the background of the work?

Are the summary and conclusions adequate?

Do the authors explain clearly what they have done?

Do the authors explain clearly why what they did was worth doing?
 
Is the order of presentation satisfactory?.
 
Is the English satisfactory?
 
Are there color figures Included? Y______N______
Are they helpful/necessary?
 
Is there a video? Y__________N________
Is it helpful/necessary?
 

 
 

                                                                                                                                             Pg. 2 Author MedIA                                                                                                                                 Reviewer No.

                                                                 Comments

Manuscript Number: #
 Title :
Author(s) :
 

Please type on this page any comments that amplify your ratings on the previous page.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

                                                                                                                                         Pg. 3 Editor
                                                                                                                                         Reviewer No.
MedIA

Manuscript Number:
Title :
Author(s) :
 

COMMENTS

Return to :

Nicholas Ayache, Ph.D                                                            James S. Duncan, Ph.D
INRIA-BP93                                                                            Yale University School of Medicine
2004, Route des Lucioles                                                         Department of Diagnostic Radiology
F-06902 Sophia-Antipolis                                                        PO Box 208042
FRANCE                                                                                  New Haven, CT 06520-8042
                                                                                                 USA

Mark overall judgment :  excellent poor
 5     4    3     2     1
 __ ___ ___ ___ __

Do your recommend :

________Accept as is __________Accept w/minor revisions (Re-review _______?)

______ Request major revisions and re-review

______ Reject
 
 

How well does this paper fall within your area of expertise?

______ Fully ______Reasonably ______ Not Really
 
 

Comments to the editors (not be seen by authors).
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Date :
Reviewer's Name:                                                                                  Signature: